Newest

Creamy white in color and almost crumbly in texture, this Extra Sharp Cheddar packs a punch, followed by a citrusy tang. Magnificent melted into cheese sauce, or atop a juicy burger.
$32.99
+
Our farmers' crave-worthy Extra Sharp Cheddar packs creamy rich flavor, a slightly crumbly texture, and a luscious finish full of citrus notes. When you taste that iconic East-Coast cheddar bite, we think you'll agree this is the finest extra-sharp cheddar around. And then go in for another...
$89.99
+
With complex and wildly intense flavors that always inspire another bite, it's no wonder our farmers' Seriously Sharp Cheddar is a cheddar lover's dream. This premium, award-winning cheddar is slow aged for 14 months and packs intense complexity that makes every taste unforgettable. Pair...
$32.99
+
With complex and wildly intense flavors that always inspire another bite, it's no wonder our farmers' Seriously Sharp Cheddar is a cheddar lover's dream. This premium, award-winning cheddar is slow aged for 14 months and packs intense complexity that makes every taste unforgettable. Pair...
$89.99
+
Save 10%
This ultra-light sharp Cheddar proves that cutting fat and calories doesn't have to mean compromising flavor! Surprisingly tangy, this cheese makes a healthy and deliciously satisfying snack. Try it with a handful of nuts or a sliced apple. Pasteurized nonfat milk & milk, cheese...
$99.99 $89.99
You save: $10.00
+
SCHOOL LUNCH BOX APPROVED - Daiya Cheeze Sticks come in a pack of six individually wrapped sticks and are peanut free - making them the perfect addition to lunch boxes everywhere. ALLERGY-FRIENDLY CHEESE - Daiya Cheeze Sticks are free from most common allergens including dairy, gluten,...
$82.99
+
Daiya Sticks Cheeze Mozzarella, 4.66 Oz (Pack Of 8)
$82.99
+
Ingredients Filtered Water, Potato Starch, Coconut Oil, Expeller Pressed: Canola and/or Safflower Oil, Tricalcium Phosphate, Vegan Natural Flavors, Salt, Pea Protein, Xanthan Gum, Lactic Acid (Vegan), Konjac Flour, Fruit and/or Vegetable Juice Color, Annatto Color, Yeast Extract, Vegan...
$77.99
+
Our fieriest south-of-the-border cheddar yet! Attention-grabbing habaneros offer a ride-'em cowboy, yee-haw, blazing taste experience.
$89.99
+
Moderately hot and super smooth, this cheese adds a kick to even the tamest cracker! Makes a quick batch of nachos and adds unexpected spice to the everyday sandwich. Simply put, it's a real hottie!
$89.99
+
Moderately hot and super smooth, this cheese adds a kick to even the tamest cracker! Makes a quick batch of nachos and adds unexpected spice to the everyday sandwich. Simply put, it's a real hottie!
$32.99
+
Our New York Extra Sharp Cheddar is aged to sharp, tangy Cheddar perfection. With hints of grapefruit and bergamot, this Cheddar stands on its own, or adds unexpected zing to a bowl of pasta, or atop deli sandwiches.
$89.99
+
Supremely creamy, with huge horseradish flavor, this is one delicious cheese! Adds unforgettable flavor to the ordinary sandwich, whether it's turkey, ham or roast beef.
$89.99
+
Wildly intense sharp cheddar flavor in a grab-and-go package. It’s Seriously Sharp’s complex bite that makes it just a little bolder than even the boldest cheddars.
$44.99
+
Show another 16 products